Army report says DU at Pohakuloa not a threat

Updated at 11:19 a.m., Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Depleted uranium at Pohakuloa no threat to public, Army report says

By Nancy Cook Lauer
West Hawaii Today

HILO – A preliminary study completed by the military earlier this month finds no threat to the public from depleted uranium at the Pohakuloa Training Area.

The study is part of a U.S. Army licensing application to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission for a site-specific environmental radiation monitoring plan. Public hearings are planned for next month and then there will be a comment period before a safe-handling license is issued.

So far, only three pieces of the radioactive material have been found at Pohakuloa and it is believed that the remainder, if there was any, likely fell into the cracks in the lava, the report says.

Environmentalists, however, remain skeptical.

Sierra Club member Cory Harden says she’d like to see the military experts in a forum that includes other scientists who may dispute their findings, such as Maui resident Dr. Lorrin Pang, a former Army doctor and World Health Organization consultant and Mike Reimer, a Kona resident who served 10 years as head of research at the School of Mines in Golden, Colo., after a 25-year stint on a uranium project with the U.S. Geological Service.

“The Army is prepared to say there’s no significant harm from the DU, but they’re not prepared to back it up in a public forum, and that concerns me,” Harden said.

The Army suspected DU at Pohakuloa after research stemming from the 2005 discovery of the munitions at Schofield Barracks on Oahu led to records showing that 714 spotting rounds for the now obsolete Davy Crockett weapons systems were shipped to Hawaii sometime in the early 1960s.

The Hawaii County Council last year passed a nonbinding resolution requesting the military halt live-fire training exercises at PTA until it was determined if depleted uranium was there. The Army, however, has not stopped exercises.

Howard Sugai, chief public affairs officer for the Army’s Pacific region, said the Nuclear Regulatory Commission will help the Army establish procedures to deal with the DU.

“They will establish the guidelines,” Sugai said. “The NRC will issue us the policies, the procedures, the protocols on which we manage depleted uranium on our ranges.”

The Army’s monitoring plan must characterize conditions at each site where depleted uranium has been found and identify possible exposure pathways, changes in site use and any off-range migration of DU to the surrounding environment.

The Army document says a baseline human health risk assessment wasn’t completed because so little DU has been found at the site, and air and soil samples don’t show elevated levels of radiation.

“To this point, the Army has only found three DU rounds at PTA. This is not surprising given the geological conditions at the site,” the July 8 report says. “If any significant quantity of DU was fired at PTA, it is expected to have quickly migrated through the pahoehoe and aa basalt flows and is no longer detectable at the surface.”

Reimer said the migration theory “made me giggle.”

“On the basis of that study, they can’t come to that conclusion,” Reimer said. “That document they sent to the NRC I think was extremely superficial and often contradictory.”

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission plans to take public comments at meetings on Oahu on Aug. 24 and in Hilo and Kona on Aug. 27. The agency will then publish a notice in the Federal Register, giving the public 60 days to submit comments in writing.

Officials said they still don’t know the extent of the DU ordnance used on the island, but said such munitions are not being used currently, nor is there a plan to. The research is tedious because records are not easily accessible, but the work continues, they said.

Experts with the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the state Department of Health and the University of Hawaii, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the Office of Army Safety have said the radiation is low enough to make risks to the public and environment extremely unlikely.

Measurements have ranged from 3 to 9 micro-R – low-level gamma radiation – an hour, which is considered safe background radiation coming from natural sources, according to the military. In comparison, radiation must reach 2,000 micro-R an hour before it is considered “actionable,” and the Health Department gets people out of the area.

But some Big Island residents who have attended meetings on the issue are not ready to take the military at face value. Even the number of rounds that may have been fired at PTA has been unclear.

“I certainly hope the NRC can pin this stuff down,” Harden said.

Source: http://www.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/20090729/BREAKING01/90729058/-1/RSS01?source=rss_breaking

Mauna Kea selected for more desecration

Posted on: Wednesday, July 22, 2009

Mauna Kea selected for world’s largest telescope

Native Hawaiians, environmentalists object to use of area

By Mary Vorsino
Advertiser Staff Writer

Mauna Kea was chosen yesterday as the site for what will become the world’s largest telescope – a mega-feat of engineering that will cost $1.2 billion, create as many as 440 construction and other jobs and seal the Big Island summit’s standing as the premier spot on the planet to study the mysteries of space.
Advertisement
Quantcast

But opposition to the project from environmental and Native Hawaiian groups could still prove a formidable hurdle for making the telescope a reality. Marti Townsend, program director for Kahea: The Hawaiian Environmental Alliance, said opposition groups will go to court to stop the project if needed.

“This is a bad decision done in bad faith,” Townsend said.

The new telescope – known as the Thirty Meter Telescope – is set to be completed in 2018, following seven years of construction. Astronomers say the project is expected to spur big advances in their field and offer new insight into the universe and its celestial bodies, including whether any far-away planets are capable of sustaining life.

The TMT will be able to see 13 billion light years away, a distance so great and so far back in time that researchers predict they’ll be able to watch the first stars and galaxies in the universe forming.

“It will really provide the baby pictures of the universe,” said Charles Blue, a media relations specialist with the Thirty Meter Telescope Observatory Corp.

Mauna Kea’s 13,796-foot summit was picked as the site for the new telescope over Chile’s Cerro Armazones mountain after more than a year of study, providing some rare good news for Hawai’i construction industry officials in today’s dismal economy.

“This is definitely going to be a shot in the arm for our industry,” said Kyle Chock, executive director of Pacific Resource Partnership, a labor-management organization that represents the Hawaii Carpenters Union along with some 240 contractors. Chock said building the telescope will require 50 to 100 construction workers daily.

TMT Observatory has pledged to make sure many of those jobs go to Hawai’i residents.

Another 140 jobs will be created for operations over the life of the telescope.

“It’s a huge announcement,” Chock said.

In a news release yesterday, Gov. Linda Lingle said the decision to build the telescope in the Islands “marks an extraordinary step forward in the state’s continuing efforts to establish Hawai’i as a center for global innovation for the future.” She added, “Having the most advanced telescope in the world on the slopes of Mauna Kea will enhance Hawai’i’s high-technology sector, while providing our students with education and career opportunities” in science.
strong objection

The telescope has also been met with strong opposition from Native Hawaiian and environmental groups.

Mauna Kea is considered sacred to Native Hawaiians, while environmentalists have raised concerns about how the project will affect rare native plant and insect species atop the volcano. That opposition could affect work on the new telescope, especially if those against the project decide to head to court.

“The people are stuck. What are we going to do? Sue or lose our rights,” said Kealoha Pisciotta, president of Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, which participated in a 2007 legal challenge that helped derail plans for a $50 million addition to the W.M. Keck Observatory.

The new telescope is much bigger than that project. A draft environmental impact statement estimates that the site for the project will cover approximately 5 acres on the summit, with a 30-meter segmented mirror in a 180-foot dome housing, a 35,000-square-foot support building and a parking area. The TMT project also calls for a mid-level facility on Mauna Kea at 9,200 feet along with headquarters at the University of Hawai’i-Hilo.

Sandra Dawson, EIS manager for the project, said TMT officials have had multiple public meetings and sit-downs with residents to get their thoughts on the telescope. She has gotten about 300 comments to the draft EIS, which are being reviewed.

“What we’re hoping for is that people who have in the past been in opposition will work with us to try to make this as acceptable as possible,” she said. “We’re going to do everything we can” to work with people.
14 telescopes

The telescope will be the 14th on Mauna Kea. It will require a permit from the state Department of Land and Natural Resources, which TMT officials are hopeful won’t be delayed. Meanwhile, the University of Hawai’i is in negotiations with TMT over the project. UH manages the summit of Mauna Kea, and Dawson said the university will get observing time in the new telescope as part of a lease.

TMT officials expect to finalize the EIS on the project by the end of the year. They expect to kick off construction in 2011.

Virginia Hinshaw, UH-Manoa chancellor, said in a statement that the project is “tremendously exciting for Hawai’i and will bring benefits both to our astronomers and certainly to our citizens through workforce development and science education.”

She added the decision to choose the Islands as the site for the cutting-edge telescope highlights the role “of Hawai’i … (in) advances in our understanding of the universe.”

UH-Hilo Chancellor Rose Tseng said the new telescope “holds great potential.”

“I’m doing everything I can to create the conditions under which a project like TMT can succeed on Mauna Kea and benefit the community,” she said.

TMT will be built by the University of California, the California Institute of Technology and the Association of Canadian Universities for Research in Astronomy.

About $300 million has been pledged so far for the construction of the new telescope, said TMT’s media specialist Blue. About $50 million has been pledged for design and development.

He said despite the economic downturn, “we’re confident the remaining funding can be secured.”

The new telescope will allow astronomers the clearest picture of space ever.

With it, astronomers will be able to view objects nine times fainter than with existing telescopes.

“It’s going to keep Hawai’i at the center of the world of astronomy,” said Taft Armandroff, director of the W.M. Keck Observatory, which has twin telescopes atop Mauna Kea with 10-meter mirrors, currently the world’s largest. “It’s a real validation that Mauna Kea is one of the absolute best places in the world to do astronomy.”

Reach Mary Vorsino at mvorsino@honoluluadvertiser.com.

Source: http://www.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/20090722/NEWS01/907220344/Mauna+Kea+selected+for+world+s+largest+telescope

Waimanalo wants Air Force to return Bellows land

Board asked to seek Bellows land

A proposed resolution claims the Air Force no longer needs 400 acres and should give it up

By Kaylee Noborikawa

POSTED: 01:30 a.m. HST, Jul 12, 2009

20090712_nws_bellows1

Some Waimanalo residents are calling for the U.S. Air Force to return about 400 acres from Bellows Air Force Station because the land is being used for recreation rather than critical military purposes.

“I’m asking the neighborhood board to adopt a resolution which asks for the return (of the land), and I expect the neighborhood board to transfer that resolution to Congress, our senators, and President Obama,” said Joseph Ryan, a former member of the Waimanalo Neighborhood Board and a Waimanalo resident since the 1960s.

Ryan drafted the resolution after receiving an environmental assessment in March by the U.S. Air Force which wants to construct at Bellows 48 vacation rentals, a nine-hole disc golf course, a community activity center, a car wash, a water park, a resort pool, and a nine-hole par-3 golf course.

Ryan said his action is not related to the military’s closing of Bellows to the public for a month recently. The popular beach and camping area was closed because of misuse and vandalism, military officials had said. It was reopened over the July 4th weekend.

According to Ryan, the state should get the land, which was appropriated by President Woodrow Wilson in 1917, since the military is no longer using it for its original military purpose.

A total of 1,510 acres of ceded land was appropriated in the presidential executive order, but in 1999, about 1,100 acres were transferred to the U.S. Marine Corps, according to the Corps.

“When the Air Force decided by its EA to use the base for recreational services, they made the decision that this is no longer critical defense purposes. Recreation is a collateral purpose. It doesn’t support the primary mission,” said Ryan.

The military responded by saying that although the primary mission is recreation, the Armed Forces continue to train on the land. Hickam’s 15th Security Forces Squadron, U.S. Marine Corps security forces, and the Honolulu Police Department use Bellows for training, including building clearing, hostage negotiation training, and robbery response.

“Bellows continues to fill key roles in troop recreation and training,” said Capt. Christy Stravolo of the Pacific Air Forces Public Affairs. “One of the key priorities of the Air Force Chief of Staff is airman morale and readiness. Bellows contributes to this priority every day.”

The Bellows Air Force Station offers cabins, camping sites, and other recreational activities for military retirees, soldiers in the reserve/guard, active military members, and U.S. Department of Defense civilians. According to Stravolo, 500,000 visitors use Bellows’ facilities every year.

“Troops can’t afford the expensive commercial establishments, so here’s a chance they have to relax with their families at a very reasonable price. The fees they charge are quite a bit less than Waikiki,” said Gen. Robert Lee.

Lee is in charge of the Army National Guard at Bellows and trains newly promoted sergeants on unit tactics.

“I think we can work it out with the community. We allow the Waimanalo Neighborhood Board to use our facility for their meetings; I believe we can work out a good solution,” Lee said.

MEETING

The Waimanalo Neighborhood Board will meet at 7:30 p.m. tomorrow at Waimanalo Public Library to discuss the recreational use of land at Bellows Air Force Station. Public testimony is welcome.

Source: http://www.starbulletin.com/news/20090712_Board_asked_to_seek_Bellows_land.html

Haleakala telescope offers no direct benefits, desecrates a sacred place

VIEWPOINT: Haleakala telescope offers no direct benefits, desecrates a sacred place

By KIOPE RAYMOND

POSTED: June 21, 2009

http://www.mauinews.com/page/content.detail/id/520038.html?nav=18

The summit area of Haleakala does not have a comprehensive, community-driven, scientifically based and culturally appropriate management plan.

A partial list of Haleakala summit users would include 1.7 million annual visitors to Haleakala National Park; National Park Service employees; staff of Coast Guard communication towers, TV and phone towers; the UH Institute for Astronomy, its lessees and partners; commercial activity businesses and Native Hawaiian practitioners.

As a result, individual entities, like the Institute for Astronomy, have their own long-range plans for development. Without a comprehensive plan for the summit area, inappropriate projects like the construction of the 143-foot, 14-story Advanced Technology Solar Telescope on the summit of Haleakala can be developed on separate parcels that have adverse impact on the whole.

If one wanted to build a 14-story hotel on Maui, it would not be allowed! If one wanted to build a 14-story public education complex on Maui, it would not be allowed! If one wanted to build a 14-story structure to house the houseless on Maui, it would not be allowed!

Yet, we would allow the construction of a 14-story observatory that will top out at approximately 10,123 feet – 100 feet higher than the highest point on the island – within a summit area that has no comprehensive master plan; that is acknowledged to be a sacred place; that is on what the state says are 18 acres of ceded lands which accrue just $1 per annum, therefore just 20 cents pro rata share for the benefit of Native Hawaiians in rent from the Institute for Astronomy to the state of Hawaii; that is going to need an additional Maui Electric substation and power for the equivalent of 4,000 homes; and is, lest we forget, on state conservation district land.

A fallacious argument is made that because Hawaiians revered astronomy, then anything done in the 21st century with respect to astronomy is automatically consistent with Hawaiian spirituality. It’s like saying because Hawaiians revere kalo and because a company wants to genetically modify kalo they’re actually not at cross purposes – they both have proper respect for kalo, they’re just looking at it differently. That logic is unacceptable!

It is also unacceptable logic that infers that during the 19th century period of Hawaiian monarchy, Kalakaua introduced telescopes to Hawaii and he would be – and we should be – in favor of the ATST. Well, Kalakaua also introduced electricity to Hawaii. Shouldn’t we, by the same logic, light up Maui – or at least the top of Haleakala – at night with electric lights? Of course not!

The proximity – less than 100 feet – of the 14-story structure during six or more years’ construction phase and then at least 50 more years of planned existence to a place of worship is painful to those who want to offer respectful prayer. It is a place of spiritual epiphany. It is even more painful to those who want to practice Hawaiian religious ceremonies with offerings to Hawaiian deities to see the desecration of digging into the rock, a kino lau or physical manifestation of the goddess Pele, and the possible loss, or “incidental take,” of ‘ua’u. The petrel is considered an ‘aumakua, or family ancestral spirit.

When I recall the mo’olelo of Maui snaring the sun, I remember that Maui’s act had direct benefit for his own family and to all Hawaiians. I respectfully doubt and question the direct benefit to all Hawaiians and residents of Maui that is derived from the construction of the proposed ATST.

The supplemental draft environmental impact statement public comment period ends June 22. The final EIS is currently scheduled to be finished in late summer or fall. During a 30-day period thereafter, in addition to an internal final review, the public and other agencies can comment on the final EIS prior to final action on the proposal. The DLNR Conservation District Use application 180-day permit process and public hearings are currently scheduled for this winter and next spring. More information on this issue can be obtained at www.kilakilahaleakala.org/ and atst.nso.edu.

* Kiope Raymond, a Native Hawaiian, is a tenured associate professor of Hawaiian language and culture at Maui Community College and president of the nonprofit Kilakila o Haleakala, which works to protect the sanctity of the mountain. He lives in Waiohuli.

Demonstration against Military Occupation of Waimanalo

Please support this action by the Waimanalo residents to resist the military build up in their c0mmunity.

On 6/18/09 8:05 AM, “iwalani keliihoomalu” <keliihoomalu@hotmail.com> wrote:

Aloha,

We are organizing a peaceful demonstration of protest. We the positive re-action along with other soverign groups will be coming together to take a stand. We will be excercising our right to say enough is enough. The health center is our place that provides us and continues to service and meet our needs. We have been in discussion with them to release a portion of land that they do not need but chooses to excercise the authority of power to keep us oppressed and seperate us from the land of our inherent birth right. The choice to continue to flaunt it and continually push their military authority is a misuse of their authority antagonizes the whole situation. Which instigates a reaction. Join us in an effort to take a stand and say not in waimanalo and not at the waimanalo health center. We will be in front on Kalanianaole Hwy across from Bellow Air Force Base to hold signs and let them know we do not agree and there is something wrong in their decision. We will be parking on mauka side in Bellows and using Tinker Road as a cross walk to hold signs. We will be there from 9:00 am- 1:00pm. Bring chair, water and your message. I can be reached at 954-7124.

Aloha kakou,
Mabel Ann & Solomon C. Spencer Jr. & Kawehi Kanui Gill

Who : Waimanalo community
What: “Peaceful Demonstration of Protest”
When: June 27, 2009 Saturday
Time: 9:00 am – 1 pm
Where: In front of Bellow’s Air Force Base on Kalanianaole
Why: To support the Waimanalo Community in protest of the closing of our bellow beach and the return of our Native lands.

Join us and take a stand and add your voice in support.


—–Original Message—–
From: May Akamine
Sent: Wednesday, June 17, 2009 6:04 PM
To: All Staff
Subject: Signs in Back of Waimanalo Health Center

All Staff –

Just want you to know that a contractor from the military posted 2 “No Trespassing” signs behind our clinic- see attached photos. Please leave the signs as is; please do not deface it; do not remove it, etc. But, please feel free to continue to walk/work in our Garden.

I will be contacting the military PR liaison Major Crouch, w/ cc to our Board of Directors, our Waimanalo Neighborhood Board Chair Kekoa Ho, Representative Chris Lee, etc. to find out what is going on. I’ll get back to you all when I get more info. Mahalo for your cooperation.

signs-by-waimanalo-health-ctr-adult-clinic-6-17-091 signs-by-waimanalo-health-ctr-garden-6-17-091

Aloha –
May Akamine, RN, MS
Executive Director
Waimanalo Health Center
41-1347 Kalanianaole Hwy
Waimanalo, HI 96795
Personal Line: (808) 954-7107
Cell: (808) 225-9614
Clinic Phone: (808) 259-7948
Fax: (808) 259-6449
www.waimanalohc.org <http://www.waimanalohc.org/>

Marines train for Afghanistan war in Waimanalo

Marines prepare for Afghanistan in Waimanalo “village”

By Gregg K. Kakesako

POSTED: 01:30 a.m. HST, Jun 15, 2009

Sgt. Michael Osburn cautiously led his squad of Kaneohe Marines into the remote village.

With him was Lance Cpl. Robert Bacigalupo. Like many in his squad of 14 Marines, this was Bacigalupo’s first time in a combat zone. The town was littered with plastic bottles, discarded car tires, rags, trash and items Marines call “battlefield clutter.” Loud music from a nearby mosque echoed through the town square.

Osburn, relying on his experiences from earlier Afghan and Iraq combat tours, reached for a pack of Marlboros in his combat vest as he began his “meet and greets” with the locals in the town square. He’s learned that cigarettes were the quickest way to prove that his squad’s intentions were friendly.

As he met with the town’s leaders, an insurgent sniper cut down three of his Marines. Osburn quickly apologized to the mayor for his abrupt departure and turned to handle the crisis.

The crisis and the Afghani village, however, were not real, but rather a combat drill at the Marine’s two-year-old urban warfare training site in Waimanalo last week.

Here Kaneohe’s “Lava Dogs” were preparing for a seven-month deployment to Afghanistan.

Before they leave for Afghanistan, Osburn and the more than 900 Kaneohe Marines belonging to the 1st Battalion, 3rd Marine Regiment, will be participating in numerous battle drills and combat scenarios at Kaneohe Bay, Waimanalo, Pohakuloa Training Area on the Big Island and the Marine Corps Air Ground Combat Center at Twentynine Palms, Calif., about halfway between Los Angeles and Las Vegas.

This will be the battalion’s fifth combat tour. It went to Afghanistan in 2006 and was sent to Iraq in 2004, 2007 and again last year.

Osburn, who deployed to Afghanistan in 2006, said parts of the country resemble the training areas in the mountains near Kahuku.

Last week Bravo Company, with about 180 Marines, completed part of its first phase of training at Bellows Air Force Station, where shipping containers have been used to replicate an Afghan town. The containers are painted tan with windows and doors cut into them. Some are stacked on top of one another to transform them into two-story buildings, which are supposed to be Afghan schools, government offices and shops. There was even a turquoise wooden dome added to one of the shipping container complexes to make it look like a mosque.

The Marines get a quick critique after each exercise. After one session, Staff Sgt. Lee LeGrande, an exercise controller, praised Osburn for using cigarettes to get closer to the “villagers” and for apologizing to the mayor before breaking off his courtesy visit.

However, LeGrande also criticized the squad for failing to get approval before firing on the “mosque” where the Marines believed the sniper had been hiding. He also cautioned the squad to be more careful before aiding the wounded Marines or they could end up becoming a victim of the sniper.

Chief Warrant Officer Craig Marshall, a battalion gunner who has done four Iraqi combat tours, said during the first phase Marines are taught basics of the culture where they will be deployed; procedures and techniques necessary to man a vehicle checkpoint and conduct patrols through villages and towns; and ways to identify the various homemade bombs used by insurgents.

Nearly 50 Afghan nationals were recruited in Southern California and brought to Hawaii. They not only participated in checkpoint and village exercises but also prepared Afghani dishes for the Marines to sample.

The Kaneohe Marines will spend a couple of weeks at Pohakuloa later this summer where intense live-fire exercises will be held. They will then return to Waimanalo and live and work for several days in the same training area, which will be turned into an Afghan forward operating base. In September the 1st Battalion will spend nearly a month at Twentynine Palms before going on leave and deploying to Afghanistan at the end of the year.

Source: http://www.starbulletin.com/news/20090615_Marines_prepare_for_Afghanistan_at_a_village_in_Waimanalo.html

Study says sonar harmful to whales

According to the following article in the AP, a new study that was partially funded by the Office of Naval Research supports the theory that sonar has negative effects on beaked whales.  This has been a major contention against the powerful Navy sonar exercises that are conducted in Hawaiian waters several times a year.

Whale study implicates sonar

By Audrey McAvoy
Associated Press

POSTED: 01:30 a.m. HST, Jun 12, 2009

A new study offers evidence to support the theory that beaked whales get the bends when they surface rapidly, possibly after being startled by naval sonar.

The report could help scientists understand why beaked whales appear to be more vulnerable to the potentially harmful effects of sonar than other marine mammals.

Together with other studies, the results might also help scientists and regulators think of how navies could adjust their sonar use during training to prevent beaked whale strandings and deaths.

“It provides more evidence that beaked whales that are being found dead in association with naval sonar activities are likely to be getting decompression sickness,” said Robin Baird, a marine biologist at Cascadia Research Collective and one of the report’s authors.

The study, published online this week in the journal Respiratory Physiology and Neurobiology, uses data gathered from three species in the beaked whale family. Two of the species, Cuvier’s and Blainville’s, were observed in Hawaii waters. The third, northern bottlenose whales, were studied off Nova Scotia, Canada.

Military ships use midfrequency active sonar by firing bursts of sound, or “pings,” through the water and listening for an echo off a vessel’s hull. The technology has become increasingly important to the Navy as other countries, including China, have built quieter diesel-powered submarines that elude passive sonar detection.

In 2000, several beaked whales washed ashore with bleeding around their brains and ears during Navy exercises in the Bahamas. Scientists believe the bleeding may have been caused by bubbles that formed in the whales’ bloodstreams when they surfaced more quickly than normal.

The Navy has since agreed to adopt some measures to protect whales, such as having ships turn off their sonar when sailors spot marine mammals nearby. But it has strongly resisted many more stringent restrictions, saying there is not enough scientific evidence to require them.

The Navy is also pushing for more research in the area, budgeting $26 million per year over the next five years to understand how marine mammals hear and how sound affects them.

The new beaked whale study was also funded in part by the Office of Naval Research.

Beaked whales are among the least studied marine mammals because their populations are small and they spend most of their time deep below the surface.

So little is known about how the whales react to underwater sounds that it has been difficult for regulators to determine how the Navy should limit its use of sonar during training to protect marine mammals.

Last year the U.S. Supreme Court rejected a lawsuit filed by environmentalists seeking more restrictions on navy sonar because it was not clear how many marine mammals would be harmed by exercises. The justices said the restrictions would lead to an inadequately trained Navy, jeopardizing the safety of the fleet.

The study concludes the animals are at higher risk of suffering the bends because they live with extremely high levels of nitrogen in their blood and body tissues.

Nitrogen builds in mammals, including humans, when they dive. Beaked whales likely accumulate such high levels of nitrogen because they repeatedly dive to great depths — sometimes almost 5,000 feet below the surface — for long periods of more than an hour.

When mammals ascend slowly, the nitrogen in their blood stays dissolved. But when they surface too quickly, the nitrogen comes out in bubbles. This gives them a form of decompression sickness, or the bends, a condition also known to scuba divers. Skin divers who make repeated deep dives are also susceptible.

Andreas Fahlman, study co-author and visiting investigator at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts, said scientists would need to study what sound levels and frequencies might be prompting beaked whales to react in a way that is dangerous.

“What do the animals do? Do they swim faster to the surface?” Fahlman said. “How do these behaviors change?”

Since 1960 there have been 41 cases of mass strandings of Cuvier’s beaked whales around the world, according to a 2006 report in the Journal of Cetacean Research and Management.

Studies examining whether whale populations are increasing, decreasing or are stable are also needed, Baird said. Currently, nothing is known about the population trends of the world’s 21 beaked whale species, regardless of where they are in the world.”

A new study offers evidence to support the theory that beaked whales get the bends when they surface rapidly, possibly after being startled by naval sonar.

The report could help scientists understand why beaked whales appear to be more vulnerable to the potentially harmful effects of sonar than other marine mammals.

Together with other studies, the results might also help scientists and regulators think of how navies could adjust their sonar use during training to prevent beaked whale strandings and deaths.

“It provides more evidence that beaked whales that are being found dead in association with naval sonar activities are likely to be getting decompression sickness,” said Robin Baird, a marine biologist at Cascadia Research Collective and one of the report’s authors.

The study, published online this week in the journal Respiratory Physiology and Neurobiology, uses data gathered from three species in the beaked whale family. Two of the species, Cuvier’s and Blainville’s, were observed in Hawaii waters. The third, northern bottlenose whales, were studied off Nova Scotia, Canada.

Military ships use midfrequency active sonar by firing bursts of sound, or “pings,” through the water and listening for an echo off a vessel’s hull. The technology has become increasingly important to the Navy as other countries, including China, have built quieter diesel-powered submarines that elude passive sonar detection.

In 2000, several beaked whales washed ashore with bleeding around their brains and ears during Navy exercises in the Bahamas. Scientists believe the bleeding may have been caused by bubbles that formed in the whales’ bloodstreams when they surfaced more quickly than normal.

The Navy has since agreed to adopt some measures to protect whales, such as having ships turn off their sonar when sailors spot marine mammals nearby. But it has strongly resisted many more stringent restrictions, saying there is not enough scientific evidence to require them.

The Navy is also pushing for more research in the area, budgeting $26 million per year over the next five years to understand how marine mammals hear and how sound affects them.

The new beaked whale study was also funded in part by the Office of Naval Research.

Beaked whales are among the least studied marine mammals because their populations are small and they spend most of their time deep below the surface.

So little is known about how the whales react to underwater sounds that it has been difficult for regulators to determine how the Navy should limit its use of sonar during training to protect marine mammals.

Last year the U.S. Supreme Court rejected a lawsuit filed by environmentalists seeking more restrictions on navy sonar because it was not clear how many marine mammals would be harmed by exercises. The justices said the restrictions would lead to an inadequately trained Navy, jeopardizing the safety of the fleet.

The study concludes the animals are at higher risk of suffering the bends because they live with extremely high levels of nitrogen in their blood and body tissues.

Nitrogen builds in mammals, including humans, when they dive. Beaked whales likely accumulate such high levels of nitrogen because they repeatedly dive to great depths — sometimes almost 5,000 feet below the surface — for long periods of more than an hour.

When mammals ascend slowly, the nitrogen in their blood stays dissolved. But when they surface too quickly, the nitrogen comes out in bubbles. This gives them a form of decompression sickness, or the bends, a condition also known to scuba divers. Skin divers who make repeated deep dives are also susceptible.

Andreas Fahlman, study co-author and visiting investigator at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts, said scientists would need to study what sound levels and frequencies might be prompting beaked whales to react in a way that is dangerous.

“What do the animals do? Do they swim faster to the surface?” Fahlman said. “How do these behaviors change?”

Since 1960 there have been 41 cases of mass strandings of Cuvier’s beaked whales around the world, according to a 2006 report in the Journal of Cetacean Research and Management.

Studies examining whether whale populations are increasing, decreasing or are stable are also needed, Baird said. Currently, nothing is known about the population trends of the world’s 21 beaked whale species, regardless of where they are in the world.”

“King of Pork”

May 31, 2009

In Battle to Cut Billions, a Spotlight on One Man

By DAVID D. KIRKPATRICK and DAVID M. HERSZENHORN

WASHINGTON – Near the end of a two-hour hearing on a special war-spending bill this month, Senator Daniel K. Inouye, in his slow and rumbling voice, finally said the words that defense lobbyists across Washington had been hoping to hear: there was “good reason to be optimistic.”

Mr. Inouye, Democrat of Hawaii, was answering a fellow senator’s question about the future of Boeing’s mammoth C-17 cargo plane. But from Mr. Inouye, the taciturn new chairman of the Appropriations Committee, the comment was also the latest reminder that, as the Obama administration lifts its ax over hundreds of billions of dollars in military contracts that the Pentagon says it no longer needs, he is the industry’s last line of defense.

Mr. Inouye is best positioned to fulfill or frustrate the administration’s hopes of reining in runaway procurement costs. That makes him the object of intense courtship from industry executives, senators and even a certain Hawaiian in the White House.

“In the Senate, the buck stops with Chairman Inouye,” said David Morrison, a lobbyist for Boeing and a former aide to Mr. Inouye, the company with the most at stake in the proposed cuts.

Critics, though, say Mr. Inouye – a self-described “king of pork” responsible for nearly a billion dollars in earmarks each year – is also the most potent remaining champion of the parochialism that for decades has made major military projects hard to kill.

“There is no question a lot of this stuff is going to get put back by Congress,” said Senator Tom Coburn, Republican of Oklahoma. “And the question is, why? Do we need more C-17s, or are we trying to keep people employed on a weapons system that we already have enough of?” Now, Mr. Coburn said, “We’ll see what the priorities are.”

Mr. Inouye is the last of a vanishing breed of powerful old-school appropriators. His predecessor as appropriations chairman, Senator Robert C. Byrd, 91, Democrat of West Virginia, is enfeebled by age. Another former chairman, Ted Stevens, the Alaska Republican whom Mr. Inouye called “brother,” lost re-election last year amid ethics charges.

And in the House, Representative John P. Murtha of Pennsylvania, the top Democrat on the defense appropriations subcommittee, is under a cloud because of federal investigations into lobbyists, contractors and other lawmakers with ties to his office.

“Inouye is the last of the old bulls,” said Steve Ellis of the nonpartisan Taxpayers for Common Sense, which tracks Congressional spending. “The others have been gored.”

In an interview, Mr. Inouye said he seeks only the country’s security and its soldiers’ safety as he reviews the budget presented by Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates. “If we agree with the secretary, we go along,” Mr. Inouye said. “And if we don’t, we act accordingly.”

But he also hinted of conflict ahead when he takes up the main defense budget. “You’ll see some interesting activity when the big bill comes up,” he chuckled.

Elected to Congress in 1959, two years before President Obama was born, Mr. Inouye is known as a war hero and civil rights icon. While other Japanese-Americans were in internment camps, he lost his arm leading an Army unit of Japanese-Americans in World War II.

Honoring that legacy is one of many pet causes to which he has doled out federal money, including in one case to a group he helps oversee. In 2000 he inserted into the annual defense bill $20 million for a project dedicated to the sacrifices of soldiers like himself at the Japanese American National Museum in Los Angeles, where he was longtime chairman of the board of governors.

He capitalized on his official power to help finance the project in other ways as well. He helped draw donations from military contractors with big interests before his committee. Boeing recently pledged $100,000 a year for five years, a museum spokesman said. (Mr. Inouye, 84, whose first wife died three years ago, also married the museum’s then-president, Irene Hirano, 60, last year.)

Mr. Inouye has other close ties to lobbyists. His son, Daniel K. Inouye Jr., once the leader of a punk rock band, is a lobbyist for several entertainment and communications companies that lobby the senator intensely because he sits on the commerce committee. (Mr. Inouye’s son says he lobbies only the House.)

Mr. Inouye has rescued military contractors before, most notably when the Clinton administration tried to cut procurement. When the Pentagon balked at buying early C-17s – the plane it again wants to stop buying – Boeing hired a lobbyist close to Mr. Inouye: Henry Giugni, a former Honolulu police officer who had become Mr. Inouye’s closest aide and then, with his help, the Senate’s sergeant-at-arms.

A month later, Mr. Inouye, then chairman of the military spending panel, wrote to the defense secretary urging the acquisition of more C-17s, and production continued for 15 more years. Now, the pressure from all sides is far more intense. The president has repeatedly called the senator, aides say, to talk about priorities like passing the war-spending bill quickly – meaning without adding any big equipment programs.

“He calls me Dan,’ ” Mr. Inouye said. “I call him Mr. President.’ ”

Scores of defense industry lobbyists, meanwhile, are reminding Mr. Inouye of his past support for threatened programs, including the missile defense system, partly based in Hawaii, or the Army’s “future combat systems,” a pet project of his friend and fellow Japanese-American from Hawaii, Gen. Eric K. Shinseki, now the veterans affairs secretary.

As Mr. Inouye prepared for the Senate defense budget and a House-Senate conference on the war-spending bill, some of those lobbyists had a chance to speak to him at a fund-raiser this month for his political action committee at the home of the Democratic lobbyist Tony Podesta, whose firm’s clients include Boeing, Lockheed Martin and United Technologies. (All three are among Mr. Inouye’s biggest sources of campaign money.)

Dozens of senators are also beseeching Mr. Inouye to save defense jobs in their states, including 19 who have signed a letter asking him to save Boeing’s C-17.

Many lobbyists took Mr. Inouye’s cryptic “reason to be optimistic” comment as a signal that he intended to include the eight C-17s from the House’s version of the war-spending bill when it goes to conference and may add the other eight sought by Boeing in the main defense bill. Supporters of Lockheed Martin’s F-22, a plane the Pentagon has tried for years to stop buying, took heart from Mr. Inouye’s omission of $147 million requested to shut down the production line, leaving it open while the company seeks new sales either to the United States or its allies, as Taxpayers for Common Sense reported.

Mr. Inouye has kept mum about what he may seek to insert in the 2010 military spending bill. But he acknowledged feeling the pressure. “People, whenever a lot of them see me, say, ‘Congratulations, you have got a great job, chairman of the biggest committee,’ ” he said. “I don’t have the time to explain to them that I spend less time sleeping.”

Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/31/us/politics/31inouye.html?_r=1&emc=eta1