Helicopter flyovers, unexploded ordnance and $20 million for APEC security

A few tidbits from the news…

In the past week, I found myself having to yell on numerous occasions to be heard over the noise of increased Army helicopter flyovers.  This problem will worsen for Kane’ohe residents with the Marine Corps proposal to increase the number and types of aircraft stationed at the Marine Corps Base Hawai’i in Kane’ohe.  As a consolation prize, you can tour helicopters on Moku’ume’ume (aka Ford Island) this week.   The Honolulu Star Advertiser reports “Military helicopters to fly to Ford Island to open conference”:

U.S. Army and Coast Guard helicopters will fly onto Ford Island on Friday and Saturday to open an aviation conference at the Pacific Aviation Museum Pearl Harbor.

Meanwhile, Makua Beach and Keawaula sections of Ka’ena Point State Park have been reopened to the public after a temporary closure so the Army could survey for unexploded ordnance.  The military had used the areas for training between 1930 and 1990. The Army found one munition:

The Army didn’t find any unexploded ordnance in public-use areas, but it found a World War II-era 4.2 inch mortar body in a remote and inaccessible spot inland from Keawaula.

The weapon didn’t have a fuse and was transported to Schofield Barracks for proper disposal.

And the Honolulu Police Department is not worried about losing $5 million in federal subsidies to provide security for the APEC conference in November.  According to the Honolulu Star Advertiser:

The money was part of Hawaii’s $321 million share of a controversial $1.3 trillion appropriations bill that U.S. Sen. Daniel Inouye said he would no longer support after President Barack Obama vowed to veto any bill containing earmarks.

The Honolulu Police Department is already allocating $20 million for APEC security — $10 million in fiscal year 2011, which ends June 30, and $10 million in fiscal 2012.

When the Asian Development Bank held its meeting in Honolulu, the police grew more militarized.  The Hawaii Tourism Authority even helped to buy riot control weapons and gear for the police.    How militarized are we?

 

 

 

Army temporarily closes beaches to check for munitions hazards

Source: http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/Global/story.asp?S=14054713

Army temporarily closes beaches to check for munitions hazards

Posted: Feb 17, 2011 6:04 PM Updated: Feb 17, 2011 6:04 PM

HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) Areas of Makua Beach and the Keawaula section of Kaena Point State Park will be temporarily closed starting next week.

The annoucement came from the Department of Land and Natural Resources, who, along with the U.S. Army Garrison-Hawaii will be conducting work in these areas to address potential munitions hazards from past military training sessions.

“This work is an important part of the Army’s commitment to cleaning up areas that may have been affected by our past use,” said Colonel Douglas Mulbury.

The areas were at times used for military training between 1930 and 1990, and were cleaned up in the past, but now the Army is using new technology to evaluate if more environmental restoration is needed.

Traffic stops may occur.

Navy blows up projectile at Hapuna Beach

Honolulu Star Advertiser reports: “Navy today exploded a World War II 16-inch unfused projectile that was found in the waters off Hapuna Beach on the Big Island’s Kohala coast.”

“The Navy hasn’t been able to determine its age or origin”

“The southern half of Hapuna Beach had been closed since Monday while the northern half of the beach was open.”

READ THE FULL ARTICLE

Hapuna Beach shut down because of suspected ordnance

The Honolulu Star Advertiser reported today:

The state Department of Land and Natural Resources shut down Hapuna State Recreation area in Kona today after a county lifeguard spotted an object suspected of being unexploded ordnance.

Army ordnance experts were called in to investigate the cylindrical metal object partially buried in the sand.  There is good reason to fear possible unexploded ordnance in this luxury resort area. For years the military used it as an impact range.  It is one of dozens of old live fire ranges throughout Hawai’i.  Unexploded ordnance have been removed from Hapuna beach on a number of occasions.

Vision of clean Kahoolawe drives former field technician

http://www.staradvertiser.com/columnists/incidentallives/20101018_Vision_of_clean_Kahoolawe_drives_former_field_technician.html

Vision of clean Kahoolawe drives former field technician

By Michael Tsai

POSTED: 01:30 a.m. HST, Oct 18, 2010

There were many in those early days of the restoration who arrived on Kahoolawe, surveyed the spent munitions blown across barren fields and felt the injury to the island as an injury to their own spirit.

It had taken decades of struggle to persuade the military to return the bombed-out island to the state, and the fight had sparked a second renaissance of native Hawaiian history, culture and activism. The heroes of that struggle were young men and women who seemed to embody author Katherine Anne Porter’s description of the revolutionist as “lean, animated by heroic faith, a vessel of abstract values.”

READ THE FULL ARTICLE

In Wai’anae: Army delays ‘Ordnance Reef’ study

Ordnance Reef study pushed back

By William Cole

POSTED: 01:30 a.m. HST, Aug 20, 2010

The Army said yesterday that it is delaying a $2.5 million study of grenades, bombs and other ordnance dumped in shallow water off Waianae that was scheduled for October because it first needs to do an environmental assessment.

Conducting the assessment for what is known as Ordnance Reef will push back the technology demonstration project until April or May, the Army said. It said it determined an assessment is required under federal law.

READ MORE

‘Hero rats’: rodents detect landmines in Africa

Detecting landmines is dangerous, tedious work.  In Africa, rats, who possess a highly developed sense of smell, have been trained to sniff out the TNT. They are cheaper and better than dogs for this purpose.    Could rats also be trained to detect other kinds of explosives found in unexploded ordnance in Hawai’i?   With rats being one of the worst threats to the native forest, putting the vermin to work could be a chance at redemption.  Instead of being an invasive threat to Makua, could they one day be Makua’s ‘hero rats’. Thanks to Richard Rodrigues for forwarding this article.

>><<

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/8549681.stm

March 5, 2010

Can rats help clear Africa’s landmines?

By Joe Loncraine

Landmines – brutal and indiscriminate weapons – are depressingly common in the developing world. Can the highly developed sense of smell of rats help to clear this scourge?

We rattled along the potholed dirt road, a thick plume of red earth spraying out behind us.

Four hours from the Mozambican capital, Maputo, we arrived in the small, dusty town of Chokwe. The reality of where I was going was only just sinking in. We were headed for the largest remaining minefield in Mozambique.

We were travelling with Apopo, a social enterprise that has come up with a unique way of clearing mines – rats.

Hero Rats

Drawing on the rats’ remarkable sense of smell, Apopo have found a way to train them to sniff out the TNT in mines. We’d already seen them being trained in Tanzania. Now it was time to see them at work in Mozambique.

One of the biggest hindrances to development in rural Mozambique is the presence, or even just the suspected presence, of a mine.

This was the legacy of Mozambique’s brutal civil war, which lasted more than 15 years, led to hundreds of thousands of deaths and left an estimated three million unexploded mines.

Bart Weetjens, a Flemish rodent enthusiast, realised that many African communities are too dependent on overseas foreign expertise to tackle many of the ordinary activities essential for their development, let alone clearing mines.

He believed he could train indigenous people to use a local resource, well suited for the job – African Pouched Rats. Like Pavlov’s dogs, the rats are conditioned to associate a stimulus with food – only it’s the smell of TNT, rather than the sound of a bell.

When we visited Bart and his team in Tanzania, where the rats are trained, it was all very light-hearted and fun. The large, yet surprisingly cute rats climbed all over the camera crew. Now in Mozambique, the rats’ nickname – Hero Rats – suddenly began to feel more appropriate and serious.

Cheaper than dogs

We all had to don protective clothing. Heavy and incredibly hot, it offered some protection but probably wouldn’t have saved us from deadly fragmentation mines.

We watched as the rats ran along wires between two handlers. When they smell a landmine, they stop, sniff the ground and begin to dig. This signal lets the Apopo staff know they have found a mine or some other explosive, which can then be removed.

Rats, according to Apopo, are much faster than men using metal detectors and are not distracted by metal contaminants. They are much cheaper to maintain than dogs and are easily passed between different handlers.

So, from a business and economic point of view, the rats seem to make sense. Apopo provides a service paid for by a customer, usually a donor government or UN agency, so it is a business relationship.

However, the whole process is costly and time-consuming, the money available usually only covers costs, so there are no profits to be had. This means that demining is never likely to be a commercially viable business.

Up to now, Apopo has relied on research and development grants. The problem, ironically, is that now the rats are a proven technology, these grants may begin to dry up.

New sustainable sources of income are needed.

TB tasks

This is where our financial expert and presenter, Alvin Hall, had some advice to offer. Apopo raises some funds through their website and its Hero Rat campaign. Members of the public and companies can pay to sponsor and name a rat.

Alvin was keen for them to maximise these opportunities, not least by increasing the minimum payment.

And he advised them to try to establish a large endowment fund, which wealthy individuals, corporations or trusts could pay into, to give Apopo a secure source of income.

But Bart’s big hope for the future is to train the rats for a host of other detection applications, from finding smuggled drugs to medical screening. Apopo is already running trials in Tanzania using the rats todetect tuberculosis in the saliva of sick patients.

The rats can process as many samples in a matter of minutes as a lab technician can in a day. The rats have even detected TB in samples that had been missed by conventional tests.

‘Great job’

Apopo hope is to become a centre of excellence for the training and development of rodent detectors, leasing out their handlers and animals as needed and training different communities to use their own indigenous rodent species for their own detection needs.

Bart has had a great idea and Apopo is doing a great job putting his idea into practice.

But my fear is that as Apopo is the only de-mining organisation using rats, one fatal oversight could be too much bad PR to handle. Selling rats as heroes is hard enough as it is.

When I finally reached the minefield and walked on ground that had been given the all clear by a rat the day before, I was definitely nervous.

Had any mines been missed? But what’s harder to know is, was I more nervous than I would have been had it been cleared by a man and metal detector? Having never been in a minefield before, I just don’t know.

Later, I was told that only days before, a human mine clearer from another organisation working in Mozambique had begun his lunch break by putting down his metal detector, walking back along a path he had just cleared, stood on a mine he had missed and was killed.

So why should I trust a fallible human any more than an animal conditioned to believe its survival is dependent on finding landmines?

Apopo’s de-mining project is the fourth social enterprise featured in a series made by Rockhopper TV on BBC World News, featuring presenter Alvin Hall and entitled Alvin’s Guide To Good Business, to be transmitted on 6 and 7 March.

Army will use robots to clear munitions from ‘Ordnance Reef’

http://www.starbulletin.com/news/20091204_Army_enlists_robots_to_clear_munitions_near_Pokai_Bay.html

Army enlists robots to clear munitions near Pokai Bay

The Ordnance Reef project also will study the long-term effects on the area’s sea life

By Gregg K. Kakesako

POSTED: 01:30 a.m. HST, Dec 04, 2009

The Army will undertake an unprecedented $2.5 million underwater robotics demonstration project beginning in October designed to remove or destroy up to 1,500 conventional munitions dumped off Pokai Bay.

Tad Davis, the Army’s deputy assistant secretary for the environment, safety and occupational health, said the Ordnance Reef project will cost $6 million and also includes studying the long-term effects on aquatic life and regenerating coral reefs in the area.

The $6 million does not include another $1.6 million being spent by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, which placed four underwater sensors at the dump site in July. The sensors will record the speed and direction of ocean currents over a year to determine where munitions materials would go if they were ever released.

Davis met with the Waianae and Nanakuli neighborhood boards last night to review the situation at Ordnance Reef as well as the ongoing effort to clean up the training range at Makua Valley to allow more access to cultural sites in the area.

The Army stopped live-fire training in the 4,190-acre valley in 2004, pending completion of the environmental impact statement in June. However, it has conducted other training exercises that do not require the use of ammunition.

A federal judge said last month the Army will have to show that maneuvers in the Leeward valley would not contaminate ocean resources or damage cultural sites.

Davis said preliminary results of a series of tests sampling the water and sediment in Ordnance Reef earlier this year show “no high levels of metal.”

“It will be a couple of months before we get the results of tests on fish and limu,” Davis said.

The conventional munitions — as opposed to chemical or nuclear ordnance — ranges from .50-caliber or smaller ammunition to 50- to 100-pound bombs and 105 mm projectiles. Many of the bombs and shells have been in the water so long that they have been become part of the reef.

Davis said the Army wants to clear away dumped weapons from the shore to nearly a mile out, up to a depth of 120 feet.

It will be “a synchronized effort” to remove the munitions and destroy them so that the Army will not have to store them, Davis said.

“There are no immediate plans to detonate munitions that are embedded in the coral reef,” Davis said, “but it is certainly on our list of options.”

Munitions clean up to begin at Maku’u Farm Lots

According to an article in the Honolulu Advertiser, the Army Corps of Engineers is beginning the clean up of munitions from the Maku’u Farm Lots in Puna.  The article states:

The agricultural Puna subdivision, now leased by the state Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, was built over a 640-acre bombing range. During World War II, it was known as the Popoki Target Area.

“The site was reportedly used by the Navy as a target practice area during World War II,” the corps said in response to an inquiry. “No records document this but ground reconnaissance revealed deteriorating air-to-ground practice bombs onsite.”

The Navy acquired the land through a sublease. That lease was canceled Nov. 1, 1945, and the land was returned to the Territory of Hawai’i.

http://www.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/20091012/NEWS0101/910120321/Puna+site+due+for+ordnance+removal

Posted on: Monday, October 12, 2009

Puna site due for ordnance removal

By Peter Sur

Hawaii Tribune-Herald

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is moving ahead with plans to clear munitions from the Maku’u Farm Lots.

The agricultural Puna subdivision, now leased by the state Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, was built over a 640-acre bombing range. During World War II, it was known as the Popoki Target Area.

“The site was reportedly used by the Navy as a target practice area during World War II,” the corps said in response to an inquiry. “No records document this but ground reconnaissance revealed deteriorating air-to-ground practice bombs onsite.”

The Navy acquired the land through a sublease. That lease was canceled Nov. 1, 1945, and the land was returned to the Territory of Hawai’i.

In 1990, the corps conducted a preliminary investigation and found 12 practice bombs within the subdivision, one of which contained a spotting charge.

A second site visit in 1991 found no evidence of ordnance because of the dense vegetation, but it was given a high priority for further action.

The corps in mid-2005 then conducted a much more thorough survey of the 640 acres, and identified two areas of concern: a 93-acre bombing target area and a 15-acre troop maneuver area.

In the bombing target area, the investigation collected 271 pounds of munitions debris. A search of the maneuver area found a hand grenade with its fuse missing and a trash pit containing shell casings of various sizes, up to .50-caliber.

Another follow-up search in July 2008 that focused on the two areas found no explosives or hazardous metal compounds.

“Archival records show no evidence for the potential of chemical warfare material or byproducts,” the corps said.

The corps decided in August 2008 on what it called “the most ambitious” of the alternatives considered: the removal and disposal of all munitions-related items from the surface and down 2 feet. The 93-acre bombing target area and the 15-acre maneuver area will both be cleared of vegetation as necessary to allow the use of munitions detectors. Personnel will sweep the ground in lanes 5 feet wide.

Also, the corps will begin a public education campaign, which will include periodic public safety awareness meetings and the distribution of educational media to landowners and local businesses.

“In the public safety materials, the corps will stress that munitions encountered by the public should never be touched or handled by teaching the ‘Three R Rule,’ ” an official said.

That is, recognize you may have seen ammunition, retreat and report it to authorities.

The corps issued a $1.56 million contract to Environet Inc. on Sept. 22 to remove the munitions and potential explosives.

Environet Receives $70M Contract For Ordnance Removal

Another article on the Waikoloa ordnance clean up.  Senator Inouye calls it a “a big win-win”.  The clean up is a good thing. But these lands should not be destroyed and contaminated in the first place.   Why do the politicians continue to support military expansion plans that will result in more contamination and future clean up projects?  If I were cynical, I’d say they were intentionally funding destructive projects to ensure that there will be a need for future clean up projects and the funds that come with it.

>><<

West Hawaii News – Environet Receives $70M Contract For Ordnance Removal

23 Sep 2009

(Media release) – County of Hawai’i Mayor Billy Kenoi announced today that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has awarded a $70 million contract to the Hawai’i-based Environet Inc., to remove unexploded artillery shells and other ordnance from the 100,000-acre former Waikoloa Maneuver Area on the Island of Hawai’i.

The contract will span more than five years, and will involve cleanup of Department of Hawaiian Homelands and Parker Ranch lands in West Hawai’i.

“I am extremely pleased to see this important work move ahead under this contract,” said Kenoi. “It’s represents a significant investment that will make our island safer for residents and visitors, and will provide good jobs for County of Hawai’i residents who will be employed on the project.””I want to thank the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and Sen. Daniel K. Inouye for their efforts to bring this project to our island,” Kenoi said.

Environet Inc. is committed to the hiring of Big Island residents, the mayor said. In July 2009, 25 Big Island students graduated from an Unexploded Ordnance Tech I course at the Hawaii Community College in Hilo. These students will be interviewed by Environet as candidates for the cleanup work on the former Waikoloa Maneuver Area.

“I wish to commend the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for working very hard to maximize opportunities for both Hawaii companies and also Big Island residents,” said Inouye. “Cleaning up UXO is important, and the right thing to do. Having Big Island residents employed on the job ensures that it is done with cultural and local sensitivity. It is a big win-win. I look forward to more announcements of additional cleanup efforts on the Big Island.”

The total cleanup of the former Waikoloa Maneuver Area to remove what the military calls Munitions and Explosives of Concern (MEC) is expected to cost more than $600 million. Over the past seven years a total of $82 million has been spent on the cleanup effort, and more than 2,100 munitions or explosives items and 260 tons of military debris were successfully removed.

The announcement of the latest $70 million contract means that work can now continue under a new Small Business, Indefinite Delivery Quantity (IDIQ) contract administered by the Army Corps of Engineers.

The Department of Defense is committed to protecting and improving public health and safety by cleaning up environmental contamination in local communities that served as former military properties, according to the Army Corps. The Corps and its partners are dedicated to reducing risks from Formerly Used Defense Sites (FUDS) to the people and communities of Hawai’i.

The Waikoloa Maneuver project involves more than 100,000 acres on the western side of the Island of Hawai’i, and includes all or parts of the communities of Waikoloa and Waimea.

The U.S. Navy acquired the site area in 1943 for use as a military training camp and artillery range. Portions of the area were used for U.S. Marine Corps maneuvers and intensive live-fire training with hand grenades, 4.2 inch mortar, and 37 mm, 75mm, 105mm, and 155mm high explosive shells.

For more information, call Hunter Bishop, (808) 961-8565.

Source: http://www.bigislandchronicle.com/?p=9221